We had company again. This time it was company that I have been very close to, since I was about 14. Shirt-tail relatives if you will. Important people in my life.
They had somehow never seen the painting before. Or should I say the copy of the the painting to be accurate. Let’s not forget it was a copy that my mother refused to give me.
It makes me wince even now. The first thing I asked her for after what 15 years? A sentimental copy, “NO!” what if my other daughter wants it? She will still get it— Unbelievable to me really, I so cannot relate. I cried. I cried for like three days. My mother was completely unmoved. “I love you” she would say.
Hmmmmmmm.
Well she showed me who was boss. I hope that was very satisfying for her because I paid a rather high price.
So anyway, they were instantly drawn to the painting and wanted to know why I had a painting of me dressed up like a sailor-nun.
That is how much the painting looks like me, people assume it is me. People who know me well. It causes people to gasp and put their hands over their mouth when I tell them it is not me.
They ask if that is what my mom looks like too. “No” I say and pause, “she thinks it does, or she has said that anyway. Do you think it looks like her?” I turn to my sweetheart. “No, not at all” he answers.
So the question that follows is, “What does your mom look like?”
I am surprised that they have never seen her. Words fail me, “Well she has a really big head” I start. Which sounds retarded. I mean her head isn’t really that big, like you don’t look at her and say, “now there is a big-headed woman” it is just bigger than mine.
“She’s dark” I say, “she’s all brown” I mean you can tell she is my mom, we have the same feet, only hers are brown and a bit bigger. I have little feet. Not as little as some people, but small enough to get commented frequently on that I have the “feet of a baby” which is weird. Tomtom does too. Lol.
Maybe I have a picture, I suggest. I do not keep my pictures well. I have a few albums but most are just thrown in a boxes and ignored until one day I come over and spill a cup of coffee on them and walk away.
I find one of my grandparents wedding day. She looks a lot like her, I say pointing to my grandmother.
I keep looking, “here are my brother and sister at Christmas” I hand the woman a picture/card marked 1997. They are both holding teddy bears from a department store that seems odd to me. They are sitting on either side of my grandfather who is infirm at that point. It is taken in my mother’s house. I never visited that house. I have never visited most of my mother’s houses. I was never invited.
I can see pictures of people important to my mother in the shelves behind my relatives. A weird picture of my mother’s face looming incredibly large over what looks like my brother and sister in the lower left. I remember that style. I have one on my agrandparents like that. I used to think it was hysterical because my grandfather looked like a giant floating ghost.
Where is your family now?
Erm. I sigh. This is not going to go well at all I can already tell.
Around. I make a gesture around the room as if they could be in any one of these many directions. Which is actually kind of true.
They continue to look at me. “Well my sister lives here” They perk up at that imagining I have a relationship with my sister, imagining they could meet her.
“we don’t speak though”
Why not they want to know.
“Well my mother’s husband never accepted me because he didn’t want step-children. So I was never allowed to know them, they grew up in a house where I was a secret, a source of contention between their parents, and now it is just weird”
Both these people ARE step-parents. They make faces, disapproving ones.
“That’s not right” they declare.
I laugh, “the funny thing is he claims he teaches people how to be more loving” I laugh that black kind of unhappy laugh that I hate to hear people laugh.
It is not funny, it is not right, but it is not my choice. I had no power.
I look down at the photo/chirstmas card again. My mom used to always send me things like that. Or form letter Christmas cards.
I am sorry that I had to experience that. Regardless of her reasoning, however many mothers are going to read this and then worry me that I don’t understand what she went through.
They are right, I don’t understand. I don’t share those values. I don’t treat my children or other people’s children like that under any circumstance.
I have done a lot of things I am not proud of in my life, but I have never treated anyone like that. Especially not someone who was a child to me. Un hunh.
Stay tuned for part two when my company decides to lecture and learn me on adoption and how that works out for them.
Oh and P.S. the really funny thing is that my sister WILL get the copy of the painting, and it looks like ME. Maybe she won’t want it after all…lol
Posted by Coco on October 14, 2009 at 2:14 am
I know this isn’t about me and I am never sure if relating my personal experience here is good or hurtful, but here it is and Joy, if it’s not Ok, please tell me via e-mail or something, please?
I want my daughter to have it all. The china I coveted and finally got from my mom. The old family pictures. All of the keepsakes I have of her, of me, of my babyhood and childhood.
She is my daughter. The line is mother to daughter in our family and this is one line I will not break.
Because whether she loves it, hates it, is mildly interested in it or feels nothing at all, it’s one thing I can do to fully include her, though my earliest choice was so awful.
I wish you had the painting.
Posted by joy21 on October 14, 2009 at 2:28 am
No, I think that is great CoCo. It makes me happy that you would want to share things with your daughter.
This post is about my situation. People who read both our blogs have suggested to me that she would have treated me much the same way if I hadn’t been given up for adoption. I think that is entirely possible.
I mean what would have prevented her from marrying a man who wouldn’t accept me if she kept me? Then she would be motivated to act much the way she did. For me the adoption thing is just an added layer of the shame.
I know many many women would not react like my mother did. My abrother’s mother was very different. I got to see that up close and personal.
Posted by issycat on October 14, 2009 at 4:43 am
I wish you had the painting too Joy.
It all seems very cruel to me.
Posted by Kippa on October 14, 2009 at 2:35 pm
Me too. I don’t understand why your mother wouldn’t have jumped at the opportunity to give you something so symbolically significant to you.
People can be strange.
Posted by joy21 on October 14, 2009 at 2:59 pm
Well it is cruel, that was the intention. I am sure my mother will say something to the effect of how she didn’t mean it in a totally cruel way, she just had no regard for my well-being, etc,, etc,. and how she was really thinking of something else, it was my karma, I deserved it, I am not being nice.
I have heard it all before.
She’ll have some spin about how I am a baddie, or inventing this or whatever.
Maybe she will tell me she thinks my adoptive parents should have had a portrait made for me. That is always a favorite of mine. When she gets indignant about what my adoptive parents did not do for me.
She seems to be under the impression she gave me away fair and square, so what is all the fuss. Why can’t she just pretend that her “immediate” family is all that exists.
But the truth is she can and she has.
Posted by jmomma on October 14, 2009 at 6:25 pm
It’s good to find out what’s going on with you. Confronting your loss with your “shirt tail relatives” would be distressing. I am happy that you did it, favoring greater openness in adoption. I may not be nicely framed but at least I’m out of the closet.
You write of my refusing you the “COPY” of the painting as though I had a copy of the painting. In the past you’ve explained that what I feel is misleading is simply literary license. It makes it easier to make your point.
The painting was in storage when you asked for it. When I retrieved it, I found it was damaged. I eventually took it to a photographer to have a digital copy made with color corrections and sent it to you as soon as it was complete.
Posted by jmomma on October 14, 2009 at 6:47 pm
I really relate to your recent comment on my blog that you disagreed with a lot of what I said. This is of course your place to express your pov… but… You also have a picture of you and your little sister and me with you wearing an “iron-on sweatshirt that says “Happy” taken 19 years ago– not a secret.
You are both adults now. The quality of your relationship is up to the two of you.
Posted by Elizabeth on October 14, 2009 at 11:49 pm
You definitely deserved that painting. Surely it was the least you were owed.
{{{Joy}}}
Posted by Kim on October 16, 2009 at 8:17 pm
Well I know what it’s like to be rejected by a step parent, it’s not a nice feeling. My mother married her second husband when I was about 14 I think? Wasn’t invited to the wedding. He had been her partner since I was about 11 or so yet claimed that I wasn’t family to him. I don’t bother having contact with him nor with her but that’s another long story.
About the painting, it sounds very unresolved and sounds like you associate her not givingi you the painting as her not loving you. This needs to be resolved for you both to have a better connection.
It sounds to me like there is hurt that your experience of the situation with your mother’s husband is that she she took his side or at least didn’t correct his behaviour towards you. I say sounds like because I am reading all this on a blog not because I don’t think this happened.
This also needs to be resolved. If this is the case then it is my opinion and I am choosing to have one here, is that your mother would have been better off telling him that you are her daughter and back in her life and he will just have to get used to that. It seems to me that your siblings were robbed of having a good relationship with you and you them
I don’t find it good enough that you are told well you are all adults now so you can choose to have a relationship. Family connections take years to build, I feel a lot of damage has been done by you being kept away from your siblings (if that was the case it sounds like it was)
I have been most fortunate with my husband during reunion, he is very open to my daughter. We were not blessed with children together but I can’t imagine he would have had a problem with her knowing them.
Maybe you were super intense and freaked him out, I really don’t know what happened. BUT even if you had been that’s not a reason to keep you at distance from your family. I think he behaved in a fearful way and was scared that somehow his position in the family would be threatened OR he used it as a way to control your mother. Again just my view from where I stand I could be totally wrong.
It’s not going to go away, your feelings are deeply hurt over how things were for you in early reunion. These things need to be resolved. Having jolly comments saying isn’t it wonderful that you can express yourself in my view is not going to help. It reminds me of how my mother would respond to something that I felt deeply.
I don’t have any answers Joy. I hear you or at least I think I do.
I also think your mother is saying she did send you a copy of the painting? Or is it that you wanted the original? I am confused here. I think it’s ok to ask for the original. If it’s important to you and it obviously is. You are the first born so it’s your right in my opinion.
I hope you two can sort this out and that you will have validation for your feelings.
I also wish for my own daughter to always have the courage that you have to speak from the heart.
Sending both you and your mother a lot of love.
Posted by joy21 on October 16, 2009 at 8:28 pm
Thank you Kim.
She did, eventually give me the copy of the painting. It just took years.
Yes, very much her refusal and dismissal, her reasons, felt very rejecting. It is a very difficult situation to be in. I can’t say that being told I am delusional is very helpful.
My mother has pointed out that I have in fact been invited to her most current house. That is true. I have been. It was just so uncomfortable and awkward that I have not been back.
It is too bad. People’s behavior has consequences whether it is comfortable for them or not.
It is very sad for me, but I don’t know how to just smile and pretend that my feelings don’t matter.
Posted by Kim on October 17, 2009 at 8:26 am
You must not smile and pretend your feelings don’t matter. You need to sort this out both of you. I have the feeling that your mother was not allowed the time and space needed for reunion.
From the very first moment that reunion was actually possible I was in a high level of anxiety. VERY HIGH LEVEL, I mean totally freaked out, emotionally unstable, full of grief, fear, anger, excited joy, shock. All at the same time. I immediately decided not to have contact with my own mother anymore, that took a few years to be strong enough to really complete.
What I am trying to explain is that I was not functioning well, was not able to make balanced decisions, was not at all able to look at both sides of things and see the bigger picture. I made a lot of mistakes, sent her letters that were way too intense, overloaded her with my words, gifts, photos, sitckers, was in a a constant state of fearful hysteria that she was going to disappear.
I imagine your mother was not in a good place in reunion and to be honest I don’t get the feeling her family gave her the support she really needed.
I think she didn’t have the strength or self esteem to stand up to them and didn’t choose to just let them wait a bit and give you the attention that you needed and deserved. I tihink she made some mistakes and again this is just my opinion it’s not facts. I also think she was let down by her family as much as you were let down by your blood family too.
I don’t know what you can do to move forward.
You need to have your feelings validated and you need to see what your part in all this was too and own that. I think if your feelings are validated you would be able to forgive and move into the next phase of reunion.
I also get the feeling that your mother is very much afraid to lose you and loves you very much, she gives glib answers to try to make the conflict go away? I could be wrong, I don’t know.
I think you and her must have space to understand each other, the rest of the family have let her down too in my opinion not just you. Reunion is about the mother and the adult child.
By having all this conflict with your mother you are also denying Tom Tom a grandmother and missing out on a mother too. She needs to change her behavious towards you and you need to be given the right validation so that you can forgive.
I care very much for both of you.
I didn’t get the support from my family in reunion either. They just wanted to swoop in and fuck with her head and I didn’t want to let them. I got punished for keeping them away. When I did let my father meet her I felt he behaved very poorly. I was very ashamed of them and embarrased. The outer family is not going to be a prize.
I would like you to keep trying to find a way with each other, it’s worth it because there is a lot of love.
I don’t know if me going on is helpful or not…
Posted by joy21 on October 17, 2009 at 8:50 am
You are very helpful Kim.
More than you can imagine.
Thank-you. I miss you.
xoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo
Posted by Elizabeth on October 17, 2009 at 1:19 pm
Hi Kim. I really appreciate what you said about validation. I think it is so important, on both sides of a reunion.
BTW I ran into your friend Rob on the streets in Paris last March. I miss you too.
Posted by jmomma on October 17, 2009 at 4:37 pm
Kim you are a very understanding and thoughtful friend.